Failure to turn a second half dominance into goals saw Slazenger drop their first Yorkshire League points of the season after a disappointing 1-1 draw at home to David Brown.
The visitors took an early lead through a dubious short corner.
The score kick started Slazenger into life and the second half was dominated by the Horbury men.
Flowing moves created numerous chances but only one was put away by Nick Webb off a slick short corner routine and the Horbury men had to settle for a draw.
Hutchinson, Taylor, Foreman and Hellam starred for Slazenger.
On Saturday, Slazenger travel to Normanby Park, push back 2:30pm.